Acoustic Instrument
Primers

What Kind of Guitar
Should I Start On?

What Kind of Banjo
Do I Want?

Evaluating and
Buying Used
Guitars

Setting Up
Fretted Instruments

Whatever Happened
to the Banjo?

Beginning Five-
String Banjo

6-String Banjos
Banjo Pickups
Axes in my Life
What is a
Bluegrass Banjo?

Dean "Backwoods
Six" Shootout


Music Theory
Primers

Introduction
to Scales

Introduction
to Chords

Circle of Fifths

Other Articles
About Music

How to Give
Guitar Lessons

Musician or
Wannabe?

Did God Really
Give Rock &
Roll to You?

Are You a
"Brand Bigot"?

Who Owns Folk Songs?

Historical Links
About the
National Road

The Story Behind
the Story - Real
People, Places,
and Events


About the Play
Play Home
What's New
Overview
About the
Music

About the
History

About the
Logistics

About the
Cast

Synopsis
About the
Set

About the
Author

Contact Us
Home


Play an MP3 clip of 'If the Creek Don't Rise' as arranged for banjo.























Click to visit RiverBoatMusic.com's Appalachian dulcimer buyers' guide.










































Click to start researching your major 5-String Banjo options.







































Click to visit the CreekDontRise Discussion Forums
Click to visit the CreekDontRise Discussion Forums




































Click to visit RiverBoatMusic.com's parlor guitar buyers' guide.
































Click to see RiverboatMusic.com's tips for buying the Bluegrass banjo you can afford.






































Click to sign up for our newsletter about Folk, Roots, and Americana music.

Click to go to home page.

Beginning Five-String Folk Banjo - Part Fourteen - Modal Songs

Written by Paul Race for Creek Don't RiseTM
and School Of The RockTM

Remember how, in Lesson 12, we said that the rules for chords minor keys are more complex than the "rules" for chords in major keys? Well, here's a look at other kinds of scale that have their own sets of rules.

If you're interested in "old-timey" or Celtic music, you should know this stuff. Even if you aren't, you should know something about it so if the topic comes up in a room full of people you're trying to impress, you don't say something stupid.

We're talking about songs in "modal" keys. A "mode" is a kind of scale. You've already met two modes. The Ionian mode is the same as the major scale. On a piano, an Ionian scale in the key of C would start on a C and hit all the white keys until it arrives at the next C.

C major scale, an example of the Ionian mode.

The Aeolian mode is the same as the "natural minor" scale - that is a minor scale that keeps the same number of sharps and flats at the relative major it "belongs to." On a piano, an Aeolian scale would start on A and hit all the white keys until it arrives at the next A.

C major scale, an example of the Ionian mode.

Trivia Time: If the mode names sound foreign, it's because they're borrowed from the work of the ancient Greek mathematician Pythagoras. He studied the relationship between notes of various ancient Greek scales. Today's "modes" are different than the ones he defined, but we use the same names he did.

The following table shows the mode that would relate to each "scale" played only on the white keys.

IonianC to C
DorianD to D
PhrygianE to E
LydianF to F
MixolodianG to G
AeolianA to A
LocrianB to B

For an exercise, sit down at a piano and play each of these scales up and down. You'll notice that:

  • Ionian, Lydian, and Mixolodian sound basically major

  • Dorian, Phrygian, and Aeolian sound basically minor

  • Locrian just sounds weird - the scale includes a diminished triad, the only one on the keyboard.

Ionian Mode (Major Scale)
Dorian Mode
Phrygian Mode
Lydian Mode
Mixolodian Mode
Aeolian Mode (Natural Minor Scale)
Locrian Mode

It is no surprise that some of these modes are almost never used. But many old folk songs use Dorian and Mixolodian, and some "classical" and Jazz composers use them all.

In fact, if you're going through these lessons in sequence, you've already learned one song in Dorian mode - "What do You do With a Drunken Sailor?" (from Lesson 12) If you do the song in the key of D minor like we did, the melody includes a B natural, which, technically does not "belong" in the key of D minor (it "should" be a Bb).

'What Do You do With a Drunken Sailor' melody only.

This song doesn't sound all that strange to our ears since we're used to it, and since it only has one note that "breaks the rules." But some modal songs have several notes that "break the rules."

Relationship of Mode to Key Signature - You may be used to thinking of a song that is in the key of C as having no sharps or flats. A song in A minor usually has no sharps or flats either, unless you're including accidentals for "harmonic minor" or "melodic minor." But with modes, the relationship between key signature and key may not be obvious. For example, what if your song seems to be in the key of G but there is no F# (as there usually would be)? It's possible that the arranger made a mistake. But it's also possible that the song is in Mixolodian mode.

Relationship of Mode to Chord Progression - A modal tune may require adjustment to our typical "1/4/5" chord progressions. For example, an "Ionian" tune in the key may include the note F#. And it might be harmonized by going to a D or D7 chord. But a Mixolodian tune in the key of G will include F where you'd expect to hear an F#. You can't use D or D7, because that would clash. So you could stay on G and have a temporary G7 chord. Or you could substitute an F Major or D minor chord instead. In other words, the rules change.

In addition, you may have a song that sounds like it's in the key of C for the most part, but which ends on a G or even an F. Chances are the song was originally written in Mixolodian or Lydian mode, respectively.

Back when these tunes were written, chordal harmony was in its infancy; applying modern chord progressions against some of them just robs them of their charm or creates something that betrays the original composer's intentions. In some cases, the best you can do is what Appalachian dulcimer players used to do - have the melody playing against a drone note and leave the rest of the notes out.

Relationship of Mode to Tuning - Some banjo players like to retune their banjos slightly when playing certain modal tunes. One of the most common retunings is called "Sawmill" tuning, which tunes the second string up to C (DCGDg). For some songs this tuning has the advantage of taking the "third" out of the G chord, so you're not stuck playing major OR minor, the same way we use the Dno3rd in some of our previous lessons.

We'll be using a simple example that avoids retuning, but don't be surprised when you come across it.

Mixolodian Mode Example: "Old Joe Clark"

Old Joe Clark is a fiddle/barn dance tune with at least three different choruses and probably a hundred verses, all nonsense. It's also harmonized and accompanied about thirty different ways, although certain players will tell you they play the only "right version."

For the sake of this lesson, we're going to show you three different ways you could accompany this. I won't promise that you won't find a tablature someday you like better, but these are all three perfectly legitimate. Also, you'll find different versions of the words wherever they're posted. For songs like this, neither the accompaniment nor the words are important - the melody is the only thing that's non-negotiable.

One-Chord Accompaniment - We're going to start with a method that was quite popular in barn dances a century ago, keeping the whole song in one chord. We'll start out with the key of G which is hard for some people to sing, but easy to play.

Basic banjo roll with alternating bass, key of G.For now we'll also use our basic alternating bass G pattern - no Blues notes or Bluegrass licks. For a reminder of what this pattern sounds like, click this logo: Click to hear this roll played slowly enough to follow.

In case you don't know the melody, here it is in the key of G. To see sheet music with just the melody, click the little score below. To hear an mp3 of the tune with the simple accompaniment shown above, click this logo: Click to hear this song with a one-chord accompaniment.

Click to see PDF of this music.

If you want to see sheet music with the banjo tab written out, click here.

Adding Other Chords - You'll notice that the high F in the first line doesn't quite seem to fit, but it comes and goes so fast that it's not a big problem. The low F in the last line of the chorus and the last line of the verse is a little more prominent. In some Mixolodian songs, folks would put an F chord there. Again, this could be seen as a substitute for D7 which would be the dominant of the song if only its F# didn't clash with the melody.

D minor banjo chord.  The high G is technically a suspended fourth, but it doesn't affect the basic tonality of the part.On the other hand, we notice that the low D at the end of the second line could be used as an excuse to get off the G chord. The D minor chord also includes an F so it works to plug a D minor chord into those places.

Technically, the "D minor" chord we are using has a "suspended fourth" because of the high G playing on the fifth string, but that note is so ubiquitous in this song that it doesn't even "register" as part of the chord.

For this exercise, we have written out the banjo tab. To see it in sheet music format, click the little score below. To hear an mp3 of the tune with the D minor added, click this logo: Click to hear this song with a D minor chord in the accompaniment.

Click to see PDF of this music.

Dno3rd chord.  The high G is technically a suspended fourth, but it doesn't affect the basic tonality of the part.Substituting Dno3d - To some people, the D minor chord in this arrangement might seem a little "heavy-handed." To others it may seem awkward to play. No worries. In the key of G, you can easily substitute Dno3rd. By removing the F, you allow the listeners' own preconceptions to decide whether they're hearing a minor chord or not. And it's frankly easier to play. To my ears, playing the same note on the second and first string simultaneously adds a little bit of "mountain" feel to the thing.

Basic roll with Dno3rdIn the score above, simply substitute the measure to the right wherever the Dm chord appears. To hear an mp3 of the tune with the D minor added, click this logo: Click to hear this song with a Dno3rd substituted for D minor.

If you want to see sheet music with the banjo tab written out, click here.

Solo Version - There are as many ways of taking a solo on this song as there are banjo players. Plus you should know that if you have a fiddle in the group, they'll probably play the song in some other key (see below for a few examples). But we like giving you solos to practice, so here's one simple version in G. To hear an mp3 of this arrangement, click this logo: Click to hear this song with a one-chord accompaniment.

Click to see a printable 1-page version

Other Keys - This song is, frankly easier for most people to sing if it's put into D or C.

  • You can play it in D using Raised Fifth Tuning (DBGDa) and the chords D (or Dno3rd) and A minor.
D chord in DBGDa tuning
D chord in DBGDa tuning
A minor chord in DBGDa tuning
D Major in DBGDa tuning
Dno3rd in DBGDa tuning
A minor in DBGDa tuning
  • You can play it in C using Standard Tuning (DBGCg) and the chords C and Gno3rd.
 
C chord in DBGCg tuning
Gno3 in DBGCg tuning
 
C major in DBGCg tuning
Gno3 in DBGCg tuning

Conclusion

This is just an example of how you might experiment with different chord progressions when harmonizing a truly modal tune that has survived into our day. Fortunately, most of them are documented somewhere, and many of them are tabbed, so you won't necessarily be on your own.

In addition to tunes that are still written in modes, many folk songs that started out in unusual modes have evolved to more traditional scales. In some cases, folks transcribing them didn't "get" the original tune. In others, singers who wanted to use post-1800 harmonic structures changed the melodies around to fit. If you're interested in a tune that "sounds" modal but isn't quite, you could try looking for an older version of the thing, or even reconstruct it as modal yourself.

Performances and transcriptions by traditional Appalachian dulcimer performers like Jeannie Ritchie and John Jacob Niles often retain the old modal structures, because the instruments they were using couldn't play those song any other way. (Modern instruments have more frets so you can still play modally, but you don't have to.)

In the meantime please contact us if you have any questions or hit any brick walls.


All material, illustrations, and content of this web site is copyrighted 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006,
2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015 by Paul D. Race. All rights reserved.
Creek Dont' Rise(tm) is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising
program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

For questions, comments, suggestions, trouble reports, etc. about this play or about this web page, please contact us.

Musician's Friend Stupid Deal of the Day


Visit related pages and affiliated sites:
- Music -
Heartland-inspired music, history, and acoustic instrument tips.
Best-loved railroad songs and the stories behind them.
Visit musings about music on our sister site, School of the Rock With a few tools and an hour or two of work, you can make your guitar, banjo, or mandolin much more responsive.  Instruments with movable bridges can have better-than-new intonation as well. New, used, or vintage - tips for whatever your needs and preferences. Check out our article on finding good used guitars.
Carols of many countries, including music, lyrics, and the story behind the songs. X and Y-generation Christians take Contemporary Christian music, including worship, for granted, but the first generation of Contemporary Christian musicians faced strong, and often bitter resistance. Wax recordings from the early 1900s, mostly collected by George Nelson.  Download them all for a 'period' album. Folks with Bb or Eb instruments can contribute to worship services, but the WAY they do depends on the way the worship leader approaches the music. Different kinds of music call for different kinds of banjos.  Just trying to steer you in the right direction. A page devoted to some of Paul's own music endeavors.
- Trains and Hobbies -
Free building projects for your vintage railroad or Christmas village.
Visit Lionel Trains. Click to see Thomas Kinkaded-inspired Holiday Trains and Villages. Big Christmas Train Primer: Choosing and using model trains with holiday themes Building temporary and permanent railroads with big model trains Click to see HO scale trains with your favorite team's colors.
- Christmas Memories and Collectibles -
Visit the FamilyChristmasOnline site. Visit Howard Lamey's glitterhouse gallery, with free project plans, graphics, and instructions. Click to return to the Old Christmas Tree Lights Table of Contents Page Click to sign up for Maria Cudequest's craft and collectibles blog.
Click to visit Fred's Noel-Kat store.
Visit Papa Ted Althof's extensive history and collection of putz houses, the largest and most complete such resource on the Internet..
- Family Activities and Crafts -
Click to see reviews of our favorite family-friendly Christmas movies. Free, Family-Friendly Christmas Stories Decorate your tree the old-fashioned way with these kid-friendly projects. Free plans and instructions for starting a hobby building vintage-style cardboard Christmas houses. Click to find free, family-friendly Christmas poems and - in some cases - their stories. Traditional Home-Made Ornaments